Alabama Power Appeals Fenn Church Ruling to State Supreme Court

CALERA, Ala. — Alabama Power has taken its fight over Fenn Church’s land to the Alabama Supreme Court, appealing a Shelby County judge’s Nov. 10 ruling that denied the company’s request to keep Church and his supporters at least 300 feet from crews clearing trees on his property.

The utility filed its notice of appeal the evening of Nov. 10, hours after Circuit Judge Jonathan A. Spann dismissed the company’s lawsuit and denied its request for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction. The filing, Document 49 in Shelby County Circuit Court, was electronically filed at 6:50 p.m. and asks the state’s highest court to review Spann’s final judgment.

ABC 33/40 reported that Alabama Power is asking the Supreme Court for an order requiring Church and his supporters to stay at least 300 feet from utility crews working on the disputed transmission line.

Spann dismissed the case without prejudice, meaning Alabama Power may seek similar relief again. In his Nov. 10 order, the judge found the company already has a parallel condemnation case pending over the same property, and Alabama law bars a plaintiff from pursuing two actions at once for the same cause.

The dispute centers on Church’s 416 acres in Calera, where Alabama Power is building part of a 74-mile transmission line between Birmingham and Montgomery. The company has said the line will cost $248 million.

Alabama Power offered Church $80,000, then $132,000, then $194,000 for an easement across the property. In August, a Shelby County probate court awarded Church $425,435 for the easement and access rights. Church appealed that award and has not signed or accepted the money.

In September, Spann granted Church a preliminary injunction barring Alabama Power crews from the property. On Oct. 21, the Alabama Supreme Court stayed that injunction, allowing work to resume.

After the Nov. 10 ruling, Alabama Power said it was “disappointed by the court’s decision” and is “evaluating our legal options and will continue to pursue all available avenues under the law,” according to WVTM 13.

A separate condemnation case over Church’s property remains pending.