BROOKSIDE, Ala. — The town of Brookside, in Jefferson County, will dissolve its police department by Dec. 7, with officers resigning as town leaders prepare to shut the department down, ABC 33/40 reported Wednesday.
The town is working with the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office to provide law enforcement coverage, and residents should continue to call 911, according to the report.
The move comes down to insurance. Brookside’s longtime carrier, the Alabama Municipal Insurance Corporation, told the town it will not renew its coverage if the town continues operating a municipal police department, Mayor Mike Bryan said in October. The coverage runs out Dec. 19.
The carrier “has advised us that it will not renew the town’s insurance coverage if the town continues operating a municipal police department. As a result, the town council must consider a resolution to abolish the Brookside Police Department,” Bryan said.
Bryan said the decision is not a disciplinary action against any officer, but an insurance issue. He said the town has always wanted its own police department and traced the dispute to the town’s decision to stand by an officer it refused to terminate, placing him on leave temporarily before reinstating him.
The town began moving toward abolition in September. In a Sept. 30 release, the town said its insurance carrier would not renew coverage if the department continued, and the Town Council would consider a resolution to abolish the department and contract with the sheriff’s office instead. The town said any transition would protect public safety, preserve evidence and official records, safeguard restricted funds and address the rights of affected employees. Pending investigations, prosecutions, warrants, court orders and forfeiture proceedings would not end because the department is abolished, the release said.
Police Chief Marcus Sellers filed a lawsuit in October after the council discussed closing the department. A judge issued a temporary restraining order preventing the department from being disbanded, and ABC 33/40 reported the chief’s lawsuit was later dismissed by a circuit judge.
The town’s attorney has said Sellers’ allegations, including misappropriation of municipal funds and deletion of 911 records, are false and had nothing to do with the decision.
Brookside drew national attention in 2022 after an AL.com investigation found fines and forfeitures had soared by more than 600 percent in two years, eventually accounting for roughly 49 percent of the town’s revenue. In February, the town agreed to a proposed $1.5 million class-action settlement with drivers who said they were victims of a “policing-for-profit” scheme. Under the proposal, Brookside would withdraw regular police patrols from Interstate 22 for 10 years except in emergencies and sharply limit the share of town revenue that can come from policing and code enforcement.
The Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office said in September that it was not commenting on the proposal.

