BIRMINGHAM, Ala. — The Birmingham Design Review Committee voted unanimously Wednesday morning to approve demolition of three historic apartment buildings in Highland Park, clearing the way for a developer to raze the 1920s-era buildings near Caldwell Park.
The committee took the vote at its 7:30 a.m. meeting in the Birmingham City Council Chambers. The buildings are the Phares Apartments, built in 1928, at 2310 Highland Ave. S; the Caldwell Parc Apartments, built in 1926, at 2312 Highland Ave. S; and the BayCourt Apartments, built in the late 1920s, at 1054 24th St. S. The buildings sit across from the former Freddy’s Wine Bar space near Caldwell Park.
The Highland Park Neighborhood Association Local Historic Advisory Committee opposed the demolition.
The committee based its decision in part on a study by Structural Design Group, a Hoover-based structural engineering firm. The firm’s founder, Stewart Lee, concluded the buildings had exceeded their useful life and could not be repaired in a way that preserves them, and that they were not economically viable to repair or renovate.
“It breaks my heart to see things get to this level of condition, and that’s a whole other discussion about things in our city. If they were only taken care of over time, we could be reusing those assets. Unfortunately, that’s not always the case,” said Brian Wolfe, vice chair of the Design Review Committee.
The committee did not approve a replacement plan. David Silverstein Jr. of the Five Stone Group revealed a conceptual plan for 90 apartments in total, plus possible retail if the city approves the zoning. The plan will eventually need approval from the Design Review Committee, and Silverstein promised to keep working with the neighborhood on the designs.
“We’re very pleased with the outcome of the decision. I think the committee ultimately looked at the facts and the supporting evidence and made the right conclusion,” Silverstein said. “We’re going to continue to work with the local committees in the neighborhood to make sure that what ultimately gets replaced will be compatible with the district, and look forward to continuing those discussions.”

