BIRMINGHAM, Ala. — A proposal to demolish three historic apartment buildings in Highland Park is back before the Birmingham Design Review Committee on Wednesday, nearly a year after it was withdrawn.
The committee meets at 7:30 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, in the Birmingham City Council Chambers on the third floor of City Hall. The meeting is open to the public.
The owners of the 1920s-era buildings are seeking approval to demolish the apartments and redevelop the site. The buildings are at 2310 Highland Ave. S, 2312 Highland Ave. S and 1054 24th St. S. The apartments at 2310 Highland Ave. were built in the 1920s and named the Phares Apartments. The apartments at 2312 Highland Ave. were the former location of the Emilar Apartments from 1929 to 1953.
In addition to the demolition request, the applicant, the Five Stone Group, is asking the committee to approve a draft conceptual new construction plan to replace the buildings.
Neighbors have spent the past year pushing the owner for answers about the buildings’ condition. On Nov. 15, the Highland Park Neighborhood Association described in its newsletter the steps it has taken over the past year to acquire information from the owner and the developer about the condition of the buildings. The association has also reviewed the conceptual plans through its Local Historic Advisory Committee.
“The neighborhood always tries to preserve historic structures. Unfortunately the buildings have not been well maintained for decades, and engineers say they are too far gone,” said Elizabeth Sanfelippo, president of the Highland Park Neighborhood Association.
“We believe it is in the best interest of the neighborhood that our LHAC committee continue working with the owners/developers toward a design that meets the architectural quality and historic compatibility Highland Park deserves. Our participation in reviewing and acceptance of the conceptual plan should not be interpreted as an endorsement of demolition,” the association said in its newsletter.
The agenda is lengthy this month, so residents should expect a longer than usual meeting.

