MONTGOMERY, Ala. — A newly released state audit has exposed recordkeeping failures, sanitation problems and barriers to oversight within Alabama’s prison system, adding to scrutiny of a corrections department whose construction, consulting and rehabilitation contracts have drawn legislative holds.
The 367-page review, released Nov. 6 by the Alabama Department of Examiners of Public Accounts, examined Kilby Correctional Facility and expanded into the Department of Corrections’ central office after auditors identified broader concerns. The findings continued to draw coverage Tuesday as questions persisted about transparency, prison conditions and the agency’s spending.
In separate legislative action reported earlier this month, lawmakers placed holds on a proposed $200,000 prison construction consulting agreement, a contract involving a court-appointed prison mental health monitor and a $26.6 million agreement for a privately operated rehabilitation and reentry program.
Those holds were part of more than $41 million in proposed state contracts delayed across several agencies, according to AL.com. That total was not exclusively prison spending and did not represent a freeze on the corrections department’s entire budget.
The reporting reviewed for this story did not establish whether the prison-related holds had been lifted by Tuesday morning. Nor did it establish that the audit prompted the contract holds.
Auditors described “an underlying sense of secrecy within the agency, whether perceived or actual,” according to the Alabama Reflector’s account of the report. Examiners said the department required requests to go through its legal division and made obtaining routine records difficult enough that they ultimately issued a subpoena.
The review, conducted between May and October, identified weaknesses involving surveillance, staff knowledge of departmental rules, employee discipline and the documentation of violence. Auditors recommended changes intended to improve transparency and accountability.
At the central office, examiners found a handwritten “be back soon” note on the surveillance room door. The officer assigned to monitor cameras was elsewhere folding inmate uniforms, according to the report as quoted by the Reflector. Auditors recommended continuous staffing of monitoring posts and rules preventing officers from being diverted to unrelated duties.
At Kilby, an intake prison in eastern Montgomery County, an August inspection documented dirty housing areas, insects, mold and mildew, and bathrooms with broken showers, toilets or sinks. People incarcerated in nearly every housing unit inspected reported inadequate cleaning supplies, the audit said.
The review also found inconsistent death counts associated with Kilby. Auditors reconciled initial totals of 66, 72 and 68, with differences involving transfers and the facility to which deaths were attributed, WVTM reported Tuesday. Examiners nevertheless identified the absence of a standard policy defining how deaths should be classified.
Corrections Commissioner Greg Lovelace disputed some conclusions while acknowledging that improvements were needed. In his written response, reported by the Reflector, he cautioned against drawing broad conclusions from limited samples and conditions observed during individual visits.
“ADOC does not agree with every conclusion or recommendation in the report, but disagreement should not be mistaken for resistance to oversight,” Lovelace wrote.
He also pointed to efforts involving staffing, training, supervision and technology, saying improvements across a large agency take time. The audit’s recommendations are advisory, WVTM reported.
The legislative contract scrutiny focused in part on unanswered questions about Alabama’s prison construction program.
The proposed $200,000 agreement with Alina Fountain of Maynard Nexsen would provide advice on Alabama’s public works law for prison projects in Elmore and Escambia counties. Lawmakers sought details about construction schedules, financing and plans to transfer incarcerated people into new facilities, according to Alabama Political Reporter.
Johnna Ingalls, representing the department at the contract review meeting, could not provide an estimated completion date for the Elmore County prison or details about its financing, the outlet reported. Multiple lawmakers placed holds on the agreement pending additional information.
Rep. Chris England, D-Tuscaloosa, also held a contract with Karen Rea of Correctional Improvement and Sustainability Consultant LLC. Rea is a member of the external monitoring team appointed in Braggs v. Dunn, the federal litigation over mental health care in Alabama prisons. England sought estimates of the state’s future litigation and compliance costs.
A separate hold affected a proposed two-year, $26.6 million agreement with GEO Reentry Services to operate the Alabama Therapeutic Education Facility. Sen. Chris Elliott, R-Josephine, delayed that agreement while lawmakers sought more information about the program.
The audit also comes ahead of a scheduled Nov. 30 trial in a separate federal lawsuit brought by the U.S. Department of Justice over conditions in Alabama’s men’s prisons. That case concerns allegations involving violence, sexual assault and excessive force, rather than the mental health issues at the center of Braggs.
Sen. Larry Stutts, R-Tuscumbia, whose oversight proposal helped lead to the audit pilot program, told the Reflector that new buildings alone would not resolve the department’s problems.
“We can’t move into a new facility and take the old culture with us,” he said.

